TTC: GAP Between Subway Car and Platform Almost Took Life of 4-Year-Old Girl

Update:

 Ava Buckareff, 4, narrowly escaped a frightening incident when she fell through the gap between the subway and platform at St. Clair station Wednesday. She was briefly suspended at her upper torso before she was pulled to safety by her aunt. DAVID COOPER / TORONTO STAR

Ava Buckareff, 4, narrowly escaped a frightening incident when she fell through the gap between the subway and platform at St. Clair station Wednesday. She was briefly suspended at her upper torso before she was pulled to safety by her aunt. DAVID COOPER / TORONTO STAR

If you want to prevent a Toronto Transit Commission Subway Train’s door from closing and prevent the train from moving forward – simply stand in the doorway of the subway train preventing the doors from closing (shutting) or ask another passenger to stop the subway train’s doors from closing (shutting) and this will stop the train from moving forward and will alert the driver of the emergency.

see source

The subway doors opened, and for a few terrifying moments, it was as if time stopped.

Shortly before 8:30 p.m. on Wednesday evening, Ava Buckareff, 4, was boarding the train at St. Clair station when she slipped through the gap between the southbound platform and the subway car. As her aunt and older brother looked on in horror, the child became suspended at her upper torso, her head and arm above the platform while the rest of her body dangled below.

The gap that exists between the train and the platform.  It is larger at some of the ends of the platform. Brad Ross, Spokesperson for the TTC, came up with some pretty glib and insensitive advice and comments in response to this near death experience for a tiny little 4-year-old girl. Ross described Wednesday’s incident as “distressing.” But he said no special instructions need be given to parents about boarding the train at the far ends of the platform with small children. “Get on anywhere you like on the train, but hold your child’s hand and help them onto the train to make sure they’re OK,” Ross said.
The gap that exists between the train and the platform. It is larger at some of the ends of the platform.
Brad Ross, Spokesperson for the TTC, came up with some pretty glib and insensitive advice and comments in response to this near death experience for a tiny little 4-year-old girl.  Ross described Wednesday’s incident as “distressing.” But he said no special instructions need be given to parents about boarding the train at the far ends of the platform with small children. “Get on anywhere you like on the train, but hold your child’s hand and help them onto the train to make sure they’re OK,” Ross said.  Perhaps Mr. Ross should attempt to put himself in the place of Ava & Esther Buckareff and attempt to correct this situation and put measures in place to prevent this from happening again. Warning parents that the gap is larger at each end of train, up to 15 cm’s, may be a great start.  Will the TTC let another child fall through the cracks?

 

“She could have fallen. Blink — and she would have been down,” recalls her aunt, Esther Buckareff.

Buckareff, who was still standing on the platform, bent down and scooped up her niece, grabbing hold of the little girl beneath her armpits and hoisting her into the train.

Who would have known, as a passenger riding the TTC's subway, that the GAP is smaller in some areas and larger in other area's, until this near tragic incident occurred.  The TTC should take steps, (other than letting their spokesperson Brad Ross make glib comments) to ensure this doesn't happen again.
Who would have known, as a passenger riding the TTC’s subway, that the GAP is smaller in some areas and larger in other area’s, until this near tragic incident occurred. The TTC should take steps, (other than letting their spokesperson Brad Ross make glib comments) to ensure this doesn’t happen again. 
The TTC says it is investigating why the driver didn’t hear the commotion, but says it has no plans to change station platforms.It will, however, install another warning sign at the St. Clair station. 

 

According to Buckareff, concerned passengers were banging on the glass to alert the driver, but those efforts went unnoticed. She said it was by a stroke of luck that when the chimes sounded and the doors slid shut, she was safely inside with both kids.

The TTC acknowledged The size of the gap between subway and platform vary depending on the station and section of the platform, from as small as 2.5 cm (roughly one inch) to as wide as 10 to 15 cm at the ends of certain platforms, where there is a “curvature of the track,” he said.
The TTC acknowledged that the size of the gap between subway and platform vary depending on the station and section of the platform, from as small as 2.5 cm (roughly one inch) to as wide as 10 to 15 cm at the ends of certain platforms, where there is a “curvature of the track,”. It will be interesting to see what steps, if any, the TTC will take in response to this very serious situation.

Although her niece is uninjured, she said the incident should serve as a warning.

“It was a near-horrible thing,” she said. “I’d like the gap repaired, because if Ava fell through, other kids could fall through.”

Brad Ross, spokesman for the TTC, said an investigation into the incident, which Buckareff detailed in an online complaint, is underway, but he acknowledged “it is plausible.”

The size of the gap between subway and platform vary depending on the station and section of the platform, from as small as 2.5 cm (roughly one inch) to as wide as 10 to 15 cm at the ends of certain platforms, where there is a “curvature of the track,” he said.

None of the signage that TTC has erected speaks to more danger of a child or pet falling through the gap at the ends of the trains, given that the "gap" is larger and therefore more dangerous in those areas.
None of the signage that TTC has erected speaks to more danger of a child or pet falling through the gap at the ends of the trains, where there is a “curvature of the track,” given that the “gap” is larger and therefore more dangerous in those areas. TTC’s Brad Ross had this to say “.. no special instructions need be given to parents about boarding the train at the far ends of the platform with small children. Mr. Ross may feel and react totally differently if it was his nephew which he snatched from the jaws of death.

 

The far end of the southbound platform at St. Clair station, where the incident occurred, is one of those places.

Although Ross said he didn’t know the exact measurement, he said, “It is bigger than average. There’s no doubt about it.”

The Star measured the gap on several different trains at that location on Thursday. It was between 10 cm and just over 15 cm.

Ross said the TTC has tried to narrow these gaps as much as possible, but these efforts are limited by the “tail swing” of the train.

“Building out a platform lip, while static, makes sense, but when a train is actually moving, we wouldn’t be able to achieve too much without the train clipping that build-out,” he said.

Ross said the TTC has installed emergency buttons inside trains and on the platform, and uses signs on every car to remind riders to “Mind the Gap.”

“Subway platforms do pose significant dangers and that’s why we have a number of safety features in the system,” he said.

Ross described Wednesday’s incident as “distressing.” But he said no special instructions need be given to parents about boarding the train at the far ends of the platform with small children.

“Get on anywhere you like on the train, but hold your child’s hand and help them onto the train to make sure they’re OK,” Ross said.

However, that’s not good enough for Buckareff, who said it’s unrealistic to expect that parents are “shackled to the wrist” of their children at all times.

When boarding the train on Wednesday evening, she said her niece and nephew sprinted ahead, anxious to get a spot at the very front of the car, so they could watch the tunnel out the window.

“If I were holding her hand, she either would have tripped into that hole, or she still may have fallen into it,” she said. “You don’t hold your child’s hand like you’re going to lose them for life.”

 

It's only fair to share...
Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterGoogle+Pin on Pinterestshare on TumblrShare on LinkedInShare on RedditEmail to someone

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.